Conflict Resolution Lineage Authority Deferred

This output is deterministic read-model evidence. It is not canonical truth, semantic adoption, review approval, a governance decision, promotion, model certification, release authority, or proof of backend-specific equivalence.

Query kindconflict-resolution-lineage

Envelopeontograph.query.example.v0.1

ExecutionPASS

Enginepython-canonical-runtime

Input bytes6,168

Source identity

Artifact	Repository path	SHA-256
Query fixture	fixtures/queries/conflict-resolution-lineage-authority-deferred.json	sha256:aa738228ffb4449411135d77ca70d37125587d803e29810eb43e7b45df147914
Declared input	fixtures/canonical/conflict-resolution-authority-gap-extension.json	sha256:fe1c9bf153ed5de8d3fe0969e28d90d136d03c65f5bd60ce4eedfd12297a9e25
Executed result	Runtime output matched the fixture expectation	sha256:ff9e703c1b58e184f358885814f3c865664114bf28abab3153b70e4a23c0f3b3

Request

{
  "conflictRef": "conflict:authority-review-gap-001"
}

Expected canonical output

{
  "conflictRef": "conflict:authority-review-gap-001",
  "proposalRefs": [
    "proposal:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
  ],
  "items": [
    {
      "conflictRef": "conflict:authority-review-gap-001",
      "proposalRef": "proposal:authority-conflict-deferred-001",
      "targetPackageRef": "package:compliance-demo",
      "baseVersionRef": "version:compliance-demo-v1",
      "changeSetRefs": [
        "changeset:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
      ],
      "validationResultRefs": [
        "validation:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
      ],
      "reviewRefs": [
        "review:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
      ],
      "decisionRefs": [
        "decision:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
      ],
      "decisionOutcomes": [
        "defer"
      ],
      "promotionRefs": [],
      "stageOutcome": "blocked-by-authority-gap",
      "blockingOutcomes": [
        "blocked-by-authority-gap"
      ],
      "semanticDiffSummary": {
        "created": [],
        "changed": [
          "assertion:control-support-001"
        ],
        "superseded": [],
        "conflicts": [
          "conflict:authority-review-gap-001"
        ]
      },
      "supersession": [],
      "challengeEvidenceRefs": []
    }
  ]
}

Verified runtime output

The python-canonical-runtime executor returned this result and it matched the expected output using exact JSON structural equality.

{
  "conflictRef": "conflict:authority-review-gap-001",
  "proposalRefs": [
    "proposal:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
  ],
  "items": [
    {
      "conflictRef": "conflict:authority-review-gap-001",
      "proposalRef": "proposal:authority-conflict-deferred-001",
      "targetPackageRef": "package:compliance-demo",
      "baseVersionRef": "version:compliance-demo-v1",
      "changeSetRefs": [
        "changeset:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
      ],
      "validationResultRefs": [
        "validation:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
      ],
      "reviewRefs": [
        "review:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
      ],
      "decisionRefs": [
        "decision:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
      ],
      "decisionOutcomes": [
        "defer"
      ],
      "promotionRefs": [],
      "stageOutcome": "blocked-by-authority-gap",
      "blockingOutcomes": [
        "blocked-by-authority-gap"
      ],
      "semanticDiffSummary": {
        "created": [],
        "changed": [
          "assertion:control-support-001"
        ],
        "superseded": [],
        "conflicts": [
          "conflict:authority-review-gap-001"
        ]
      },
      "supersession": [],
      "challengeEvidenceRefs": []
    }
  ]
}

Declared input document

Show the complete input fixture

{
  "extensionVersion": "ontograph.fixture-extension.v0.1",
  "baseFixture": "fixtures/canonical/assertion-evidence-thin-slice.json",
  "purpose": "Executable authority-conflict slice proving conflict lineage can end in an explicit deferred decision without becoming promoted canonical state.",
  "commands": [
    {
      "commandType": "appendCanonicalObject",
      "collection": "changeSets",
      "objectId": "changeset:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
    },
    {
      "commandType": "appendCanonicalObject",
      "collection": "proposals",
      "objectId": "proposal:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
    },
    {
      "commandType": "appendCanonicalObject",
      "collection": "validationResults",
      "objectId": "validation:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
    },
    {
      "commandType": "appendCanonicalObject",
      "collection": "reviews",
      "objectId": "review:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
    },
    {
      "commandType": "appendCanonicalObject",
      "collection": "decisions",
      "objectId": "decision:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
    }
  ],
  "appends": {
    "changeSets": [
      {
        "id": "changeset:authority-conflict-deferred-001",
        "objectType": "ChangeSet",
        "schemaVersion": "ontograph.canonical.thin-slice.v0.1",
        "expectedBaseRef": "version:compliance-demo-v1",
        "affectedObjectRefs": [
          "assertion:control-support-001"
        ],
        "mutations": [
          {
            "operation": "update",
            "objectRef": "assertion:control-support-001",
            "beforeRef": "assertion:control-support-001",
            "afterRef": "assertion:control-support-001"
          }
        ],
        "rationale": "A proposed authority-sensitive reinterpretation touches accepted meaning but cannot proceed until authority is clarified.",
        "lifecycle": {
          "identity": "active"
        },
        "createdAt": "2026-05-05T04:00:00Z",
        "createdBy": "actor:max",
        "provenanceRefs": [
          {
            "carrierType": "Artifact",
            "ref": "artifact:vendor-page-001"
          }
        ],
        "scopeRefs": [
          "package:compliance-demo"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "proposals": [
      {
        "id": "proposal:authority-conflict-deferred-001",
        "objectType": "Proposal",
        "schemaVersion": "ontograph.canonical.thin-slice.v0.1",
        "targetPackageRef": "package:compliance-demo",
        "baseVersionRef": "version:compliance-demo-v1",
        "changeSetRefs": [
          "changeset:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
        ],
        "semanticDiffSummary": {
          "created": [],
          "changed": [
            "assertion:control-support-001"
          ],
          "superseded": [],
          "conflicts": [
            "conflict:authority-review-gap-001"
          ]
        },
        "reviewerRefs": [
          "actor:reviewer"
        ],
        "validationResultRefs": [],
        "lifecycle": {
          "proposal": "deferred"
        },
        "createdAt": "2026-05-05T04:01:00Z",
        "createdBy": "actor:max",
        "provenanceRefs": [
          {
            "carrierType": "ChangeSet",
            "ref": "changeset:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
          }
        ],
        "scopeRefs": [
          "package:compliance-demo"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "validationResults": [
      {
        "id": "validation:authority-conflict-deferred-001",
        "objectType": "ValidationResult",
        "schemaVersion": "ontograph.canonical.thin-slice.v0.1",
        "targetRef": "proposal:authority-conflict-deferred-001",
        "checkRef": "rule:governance-authority-required",
        "outcome": "fail",
        "message": "Authority basis is unresolved, so the conflict must be deferred instead of promoted.",
        "lifecycle": {
          "identity": "active"
        },
        "createdAt": "2026-05-05T04:02:00Z",
        "createdBy": "actor:max",
        "provenanceRefs": [
          {
            "carrierType": "ChangeSet",
            "ref": "changeset:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
          }
        ],
        "scopeRefs": [
          "package:compliance-demo"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "reviews": [
      {
        "id": "review:authority-conflict-deferred-001",
        "objectType": "Review",
        "schemaVersion": "ontograph.canonical.thin-slice.v0.1",
        "proposalRef": "proposal:authority-conflict-deferred-001",
        "reviewerRef": "actor:reviewer",
        "outcome": "defer",
        "comment": "Defer because the authority basis is unresolved; no promotion may treat this as accepted state.",
        "validationResultRefs": [
          "validation:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
        ],
        "lifecycle": {
          "identity": "active"
        },
        "createdAt": "2026-05-05T04:03:00Z",
        "createdBy": "actor:reviewer",
        "provenanceRefs": [
          {
            "carrierType": "ValidationResult",
            "ref": "validation:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
          }
        ],
        "scopeRefs": [
          "package:compliance-demo"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "decisions": [
      {
        "id": "decision:authority-conflict-deferred-001",
        "objectType": "Decision",
        "schemaVersion": "ontograph.canonical.thin-slice.v0.1",
        "targetRef": "proposal:authority-conflict-deferred-001",
        "outcome": "defer",
        "authorityBasis": {
          "basisKind": "review",
          "ref": "review:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
        },
        "rationale": "Record an explicit deferred state rather than converting the authority conflict into canonical truth.",
        "decidedBy": "actor:reviewer",
        "decidedAt": "2026-05-05T04:04:00Z",
        "lifecycle": {
          "decision": "recorded"
        },
        "createdAt": "2026-05-05T04:04:00Z",
        "createdBy": "actor:reviewer",
        "provenanceRefs": [
          {
            "carrierType": "Review",
            "ref": "review:authority-conflict-deferred-001"
          }
        ],
        "scopeRefs": [
          "package:compliance-demo"
        ]
      }
    ]
  }
}